Easy As….

Well, it’s time to get around to addressing the issues.  Thanksgiving is nearly here, and it is time to consider one of that traditional and/or stereotypical meal’s controversies.

No!  Put your tongue back in your face.  I am NOT revealing my recipe for turkey liver pizza.  That’s a Post-Holiday tradition.  I may pass it along one day, when I’m ready, but after we get past the rumor that it is the true reason the day after is called Black Friday.

The controversy I wish to look over is the question of dessert at Thanksgiving.  We have….  Stop jumping to conclusions.  Fruitcake is a CHRISTAS tradition.  Sure, maybe Aunt Booney is going to bring over that fruitcake she has left over from last year, but that’s a YOU problem.

Pumpkin pie is a holiday tradition going back at least to the mid nineteenth century, when “Over the River and Through the Woods”, written as a Thanksgiving song, had us sing “Hurrah for the pumpkin pie!”  In my days, I considered this a nice musical fling which had no connection with reality.

We were certainly a pie family.  Pie is a national tradition, absorbed from dozens of different immigrant traditions: at one time, any meal served with only one kind of pie or, worse, no pie at all, would have been considered a scandal.  But we tended toward chocolate cream, lemon meringue, peach pie (canned peaches in vanilla pudding: my mother’s invention), and, especially, apple, the only warm fruit pie my father would entertain, as he called cherry or blueberry pie “jelly in a crust”.

Our Thanksgiving dinner involved going over the river, etc. where Grandma would serve up a massive meal most of the men at the table regarded with suspicion: roast goose, tomato dumplings, liver dumpling soup, sauerkraut with caraway seed…and no dessert that I can recall.  I’m not sure we qualified for such a reward, considering that I, for one, ate some of the goose with a piece of bread and butter.

I encountered pumpkin pie only in elementary school hot lunch, where anything topped with whipped cream was a hit.  I can’t say I put it in my top ten favorite pies, but I saw nothing to hate about it.  I was sidelining myself in one of the great debates of the holiday.

Pumpkin pie goes back to the discovery of the pumpkin, and pumpkin pie as we know it was being made in the late eighteenth century.  (I am intrigued by a pie from that same era which was made by alternating slices of pumpkin and slices of apple inside the crust.  You try it and let me know.)  Controversy did not really arise until after the Civil War, when a lot of Yankees tried to explain the pumpkin pie they’d know back in New England, provoking the South to unify behind the sweet potato pie in protest.

Things accelerated after canned pumpkin was made available in the early twentieth century and Libby’s, in particular, started to push the Thanksgiving necessity of a pumpkin pie.  People who preferred apple pushed back with “Ever hear anybody say ‘as American as PUMPKIN pie’?”  Then Starbuck’s, among others, confused matters by making all the world pumpkin spice (a mixture which can be traced well into the sixteenth century as well.)  People who previously had no objection to things pumpkin now really revolted, but restaurant chefs responded to the pumpkin pie haters with pumpkin cheesecake, pumpkin sweet rolls, and even chai pumpkin tiramisu.  Not QUITE sure they read the memo.

I am afraid I have no position on the matter.  I expect to eat pumpkin pie this season, but I will not repine if none is served with Thanksgiving dinner.  (The grocery stores I frequent have them for sale year-round).  In fact, whenever pumpkin pie is served at a Thanksgiving dinner, I have barely touched it, opting for a doggie bag.  A proper Thanksgiving plate, which involves copious amounts of gravy and stuffing (OR dressing: another controversy I can’t get excited about since I grew up without that excellent invention.), is not going to leave any space in your innards to put pie.  (That, in my opinion, is an even greater post-holiday tradition than turkey liver pizza: pumpkin pie for breakfast.  Anyone who sends me complaints about THAT will be forced to listen to the story of the time I made fruitcake.  You will lose any appetite for pie.)

Leave a Reply